The best prize promotions of 2016

Over the past few months I’ve been asking SuperLucky readers which promotions impressed them most this year – and which ones left them cold. Our list covers photo competitions, on-pack promotions, treasure hunts, Twitter prize draws and mobile apps – it’s safe to say us compers like a bit of variety! Here’s our 2016 favourites…

Walkers Game Ready

At the end of 2016 most of us associated Walkers with the shambles that was ‘Spell & Go’, but don’t forget about the amazingly generous Game Ready promotion from earlier in the year. With over 40,000 prizes guaranteed to be won after ‘winning moments’, this was a comper’s dream promotion – and I reckon almost every SuperLucky reader picked up at least one football, t-shirt or sharing bowl, with a few even bagging Champions League match tickets!

Walkers Crisps promotion

Heart FM Faces for Florida

This was a fun and generous creative competition to start the year – for four weeks in January, Heart London gave away a holiday for 4 to Florida every weekday on the breakfast show. Entrants had to print off Jamie Theakston and Emma Bunton masks, and wear them in a fun photo. The twenty winners put in a LOT of effort, and were rewarded with amazing prizes that included attraction tickets, flights, accommodation and spending money. Even better – winners were allowed to take the trip in school holidays! Pretty much the perfect competition as far as I’m concerned (and you can see my winning entry in Extreme Comping).

screen-shot-2016-12-11-at-08-16-19

Hasbro Müller Kids Corner yogurts

Although the Müller Kids Corner promotion has small prizes – My Little Pony and Transformers toys – there are a hundred to be won every day over a three month period (ending in a few days on 16th December). This 24 hour winning moments promotion gave compers the advantage, with many of us inputting codes at 3am to guarantee a win! In addition, our kids were delighted at being forced to eat special Halloween and Christmas yogurts – what a treat!

kidscorner

Pepsi Max Game Ready

Another huge Champions League ‘winning moments’ promotion from the team at Walkers/Pepsi – using the Pepsi Max app to scan a promotional UCL label, you had the chance to win a PS4 and VR headset instantly. The app itself didn’t work that well – it turned out you didn’t even have to scan the label after the first time, the winning/losing message would load even if you scanned your pet cat! But the excitement level was huge – several PS4 bundles were awarded every day (244 in total) and yet again, we were setting alarms at 3am to try and catch a prize!

pepsimaxapp

Find Shorn

A clever little treasure hunt, Shorn Wines had us looking for sheep on Google Street View – if you spotted three black sheep you went into the daily draw to win a box of wine, and also had the chance to win a fridge magnet instantly. But follow the clues across social media (and the SuperLucky blog!) to track down the elusive Golden Shorn, and you could win an iPad. Addictive fun!

findshorn-1024x581

Spar Shop & Win

For this one, you just had to spend money in a Spar and upload a photo of your receipt (or input the number) on the Shop & Win website. There were instant win prizes of food & drink products on a virtual scratchcard, plus daily prizes like iPads and Bikes each day – AND a grand prize draw. It made popping to the shops a lot more fun!

SPARbanner

Iceland Freezer Fortunes

This prize draw was a simple idea from Iceland – but with hundreds of prizes. You had to upload a #freezie (selfie with your freezer, of course!) to their Facebook page – every day for a week they awarded a £50 voucher to fifty winners chosen at random, 250 in total.

Freezer Fortunes

Heathrow stories

This judged competition ran over a 14 week period last summer, with 650 prizes awarded. Entrants shared their story about Heathrow for a chance to win one of five holidays to Sydney, plus loads of lovely travel related gifts.

Heathrow Stories

Blippar McDonalds Advent Calendar

In 2016 more brands started using apps to host engaging promotions – it’s been a bit hit and miss, because of the huge range of phones and operating systems we use, but most of us are managing to give Blippar a go! McDonalds printed their Advent Calendar on tray liners this year, and for a chance to win a £10 Amazon e-voucher you needed to open up the Blippar app and scan it (or alternatively, point your phone at the centre of the image below from Blippar’s Facebook page!). A small but welcome prize just before Christmas (this one is live until Christmas Eve!)

blipparmcdonalds

The National Lottery #MegaWeek

On 27 September, @TNLUK gave away £1000 cash every hour (for ten hours) on Twitter. Having learnt their lesson from the previous year’s promotion (where a simple retweet was required and a few automated Twitter ‘bots’ won prizes), this time they asked entrants to identify the location of a doctored destination photo and reply with their answer. It was ridiculously exciting to see the winners revealed every hour!

lottery

#VMarksTheSpot

Virgin Red was an innovative new loyalty app, and their exciting #VMarkstheSpot promotion offered winners a chance to go to Necker Island to hunt for real treasure! ‘Coins’ were provided online, on social media, on scratchcards in Virgin Holidays & Media stores, and even on Virgin trains – and there was  a real buzz on online forums with people sharing tips. A certain amount of coins unlocked a ‘vault’ on the app, with a chance to win prizes – including 1,000 bottles of champagne for the first people to open one of the vaults. Once enough coins were collected, the entrant could access the final ‘Vault 12’ and have a chance to go to Necker Island! Find out what the finalists got up to here.

fbnwkg2

…and the WORST?

There have been several brands this year that have been incredibly miserly, hiding their ‘instant lose’ promotions behind complex T&Cs that bear no resemblance to the words we see on the packaging. These promotions aren’t scams – but the huge generous prize funds they shout about are misleading. Those thousands of advertised prizes will all be awarded ONLY if every single promotional code is entered on the website – so in most cases we can expect less than 5% of the prizes to be claimed.

worst

I think most of us would agree that Walkers Spell and Go was the worst prize promotion of 2016. The campaign must have cost millions – but the money certainly wasn’t spent on the prizes. In prime-time TV spots, Gary Lineker advertised an amazing ‘20,000 holidays to be won’. And at the end of the promotion, how many had been awarded via the Spell & Go letter-collecting website? A measly 796 – just 4%.

But Walkers weren’t the only Scrooge this year – how about Jarlsberg, whose flashed packs advertised £100,000 of prizes. And how many of the advertised 1,345 prizes did Jarlsberg actually give away? Well, according to the winners list, just a paltry 30 (2%). And I bet most of those were whisks and rolling pins!

And how about Highland Spring, who offered 15,686 prize tennis sets with their ‘Anywhere for Tennis’ instant win? Codes were pre-allocated in the promotion, meaning that your printed code was either a winner or loser. I’m sure you can imagine how many millions of winning Highland Spring bottles were thrown away or recycled without the code being checked – so again, only a tiny percentage of those prizes would have been won (in fact, I’ve only heard of 5 winners so far!)

What do you think were 2016’s best and worst prize promotions? What would you like to see more or less of in 2017? Leave a comment to let me know!

10 Responses

  1. Jamie Millard says:

    Walkers Game Ready was immense for boosting win numbers. The TShirts were actually pretty good quality (made great additional Christmas presents that were well received!)
    It really didn’t help that this comp preceded the Spell and Go comp. Lulled a lot of people into a false sense of optimism going from a great comp with everyone winning prizes – to the latter.

  2. Kiran Parry says:

    I enjoyed Chicago Town instant win and I enjoyed listening to capital for the cashcalls track on capital cash calls.

  3. Cristín Williams says:

    I really loved the faces for Florida competition, it was great fun trying to come up with new ideas. The muller kids corner comp has been great for me I have one of each toy they were giving away and a couple extra which are great for birthday presents for my kids friends. I got my biggest prize this year from the pepsi app and was astounded to actually win a PS4 and VR headset! All of these are thanks to your help and the hard work you put in to this blog! thank you

  4. Annette Slater says:

    Ive loved the muller corner comp, my kids eat them everyday and we are loving it 🙂

  5. Chris says:

    Can I mention here an award for the most IRRITATING comp: The ones run by Top Cash Back with the hummingbird. The Xmas one is still running. They mention big money but not sure if anyone ever wins it. The most I have won is 10p. You have to do a crazy amount of searching to get anything other than a prize draw entry. Not sure why I bother.

  6. Sammy says:

    The Plenty Trolls comp should be in here! I won 2, and was very pleased 🙂 And the prizes came quickly, and also very impressed they distributed and kept track of the trolls you’d already won.

    • Ah yes, I did well with that one! The amount of money spent promoting it (it was all over the press!) made it hard to win after the first few weeks – also the draws were only 8am – 8pm so it was tricky to gain a comper’s advantage, like we do with the 24 hour instant wins!

  7. cakesphotoslife (Angie) says:

    great to see Virgin Red on there it was a great comp x

  8. Melanie Sarah Slater says:

    Mattesons fridge raiders

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.